American Idol Season 12 Top 5: Who is the "IT" girl

American Idol Season 12 Top 5 Performance:
Judges'standing O!

It is definitely gonna be an American girl idol this year. 

Idol sends love to Boston.

Top 5 ladies on the house and only month away until we know which girl will it be.

Tonight, two themes: idol birth year songs and diva's song.

Birth year songs

Candice Glover
Straight Up, Paula Abdul

Definitely Candice is having a feel good vibe from last week's breakthrough moment. it was alright compared to last weeks. wonderful voice, awesome runs. I expect more power in the diva round.

Janelle Arthur
When I Call Your Name, Vince Hill

Lets lay on stacks of hay and look at the stars. A sleeper. That's a big guitar.

Kree Harrison
She Talks To Angels, Black Crows

Kree puts so much emotion in her voice which makes her performance so good. Janelle should take a page from her.

Angie Miller
I Stand By You, The Pretenders

Great song choice and it was a wonderful performance behind the piano. 

Amber Holcomb
I Can't Live, Mariah Carey

It was a tall order and she did good. It was not great as Mariah's version but she definitely delivered the power.

The diva round where the real battle begins.

Candice Glover
When You Believe, Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey

Now that's what you do when you do a Mariah and Whitney song. I got goosebumps all over. Another breakthrough performance from Candice.

Janelle Arthur
Dumb Blonde, Dolly Parton

Blah! She sounds rushed or behind the song. Not a good song choice.

Kree Harrison
Have You Ever Been In Love, Celine Dion

Kree is channeling Celine. She is so consistent. I feel she is the only one we can pit against Candice. 

Angie Miller
Halo, Beyonce

Over dramatic. 

Amber Holcomb
What Are You Doing The Rest of Your Life, Barbra Streisand

Haunting!

Nicki is in her annoying self tonight. 

Kree is sure to the finals with Candice if amber fails to get a breakthrough moment.

Who will it be?
Candice, Kree, Amber, Angie, and Janelle

Candice, Kree, Amber, Angie, Janelle

Considering how american is been voting in the past weeks, I predict a Janelle and Amber bottom 2. It would be travesty if Amber leaves this week but there is the judges save and Amber is sure worth saving.